Were A.A. Milne still alive, he would be turning 134 years of age today, Jan. 18, 2026. Regrettably, his days, as with the rest of us, were numbered. But in the course of them he produced a body of work much larger than that for which he is principally remembered—the children’s collections featuring Winnie the Pooh and his neighbors in the Hundred-Acre Wood.
Amongst his fiction, nonfiction, articles, poetry, and numerous plays stands a single detective novel. The Red House Mystery was first published serially in August 1921 (making 2026 its 105th birth-year). In Milne’s spirited introduction to the 1925 edition he avers that, in contrast to publishers who wish him to write to the market, “The only excuse which I have yet discovered for writing anything is that I want to write it.” It is fair to say that Milne’s delight in writing his mystery sparks delight in the reader.
Milne’s introduction also puts forth his personal prejudices regarding mysteries. First, the detective should be an amateur who speaks plain English and relies on no exclusive knowledge or scientific forensics (contra Sherlock, says this critic). “The reader must be made to feel that, if he too had used the light of cool, inductive reasoning and the logic of stern, remorseless facts then he too would have fixed the guilt.”
The second requirement, then, is a sidekick (i.e. Watson) to whom the amateur sleuth can rehearse these unyielding facts and in the process apprise the reader of the progress of this calculating reasoning.
The Red House Mystery represents a locked-room mystery—that is, one that takes place in a room seemingly impossible to enter or leave without detection. Milne was one of the earlier writers to employ the device (preceded by Arthur Conan Doyle, Gaston Leroux, GK Chesterton and others). It nevertheless dates back to 1841 and Edgar Allen Poe’s The Murders in the Rue Morgue.
The Red House’s action commences, not unlike a number of other works of British detection, amidst a house party on an English country estate. Soon after the unexpected arrival of the owner’s estranged brother, a shot is fired and a corpse is found. Coincidentally, Antony Gillingham, a friend of a member of the house party, drops in shortly afterward. Antony is introduced as someone who, above all, notices things, making him, of course, the ideal detective.
Midway through I began to feel that Antony and his friend Bill Beverly might be belaboring the rehearsal of facts. But given Milne’s convictions, we can attribute this to a democratic impulse to give readers equal opportunity with the sleuth to solve the mystery. As a reader who rarely if ever succeeds in keeping track of the puzzle pieces and assembling them correctly, I appreciate the effort.
The Red House offers all that we might expect from the Hundred-Acre Wood channeled into a well-crafted mystery: an idyllic setting, clever dialogue, and the satisfying sense of justice achieved, all executed by a charming cast of characters. The eminently amiable Bill “wouldn’t have killed anybody in cold blood himself, and he took it for granted that other people behaved pretty much as he did.” Antony, for his part, possesses not only industry, perception, and wit but the likeable qualities of courtesy and empathy, making it a pleasure to spend a few hours (six if by audiobook) in his company. That Milne did not provide readers with further such opportunity is lamentable.
Discover more from Birds' Books
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.